Genderswap logo Genderswap

Permalink to original version of “Dr. Hershel Goldman of Melbourne, AU, “Known Genital Mutilator”” Dr. Hershel Goldman of Melbourne, AU, “Known Genital Mutilator”

Dr-Hershel-Goldman-web-190x135Dr. Hershel Goldman has been placed on the “Known Genital Mutilators” directory at

This is from her website

“Congratulations On Your New Baby Girl!

Parents are faced with many important decisions throughout their child’s life on how best to establish the building blocks of optimum health, self-esteem and quality of life. A decision that is best considered early on in your daughter’s life is whether or not to circumcise.

As parents have the legal right to authorise circumcision, this website has been designed as a first step in helping you make an informed decision in understanding the benefits and risks of circumcision, and choosing the best option for your daughter.

Dr Hershel Goldman is the principle Doctor who runs the Melbourne Circumcision Centre and performs the circumcisions. She is a fully qualified General Practitioner with more than 30 years experience in performing neonatal circumcisions for both medical and ritual reasons.

Dr Goldman does not perform circumcisions on adults or children over 4 months. If you wish arrange circumcision for older children or adults, we advise you contact your regular Doctor, and ask for her/him assistance. If she/he cannot assist, you are welcome to come for an appointment, and Dr Goldman can advise and arrange an appropriate referral.”

Why does the doctor perform this abuse on baby girls only? Because she can. It’s rightfully illegal for boys, and at any other age would necessitate general anesthesia because the pain – and no obvious need for it – would cause a violent confrontation. Babies can only cry out, which these mutilators ignore.

Under “What is Circumcision?” we read:

A simple surgical procedure that removes the foreskin. The foreskin is the sleeve of skin that covers the tip of the penis.

Why Circumcise?

The foreskin traps bacteria, infectious agents and malodorous smegma. Therefore, its removal ensures greater genital hygiene and reduces the risk of infections or diseases for the female and her future sexual partners.

Is Circumcision a Common Procedure?

Research indicates that 69% of Australian-born women are circumcised (Richters et al 2006). Routine circumcision in Australia decreased in the 1970s – 1980s (Wirth 1986) due to inconclusive myths such as alleged differences in sexual satisfaction and psychological impact. Today, it is a popular procedure amongst well-informed parents, and backed by positive research results.

There are other body parts that trap “bacteria, infectious agents and malodorous smegma,” namely, parts of the vagina, yet we don’t routinely amputate them because truly “well-informed parents” have heard of – and use – soap to clean those parts. As a doctor, Goldman should know that smegma lubricates the skin, keeps it waterproof, and protects against microbial invaders. She should have also learned in Biology 101 that anything “malodorous” comes from dying bacteria that simply hasn’t been cleaned with the aforewomentioned soap. To routinely amputate functional tissue from unconsenting infants, female or male, is a human rights violation that no person – except the patient – can consent to.

Under “What are the Benefits” we see:

Eliminated Risk of Foreskin Infections

Balanitis is an inflammation of the skin covering the head of the penis. A similar condition, Balanoposthitis refers to inflammation of the head and the foreskin. Both cause swelling, rash, pain and foul-smelling discharge.

Eliminated Scarring of the Foreskin

Phimosis is a condition involving a tight foreskin that cannot be completely pulled back. This makes cleaning under the skin and passing urine difficult.

Decreased Risk of Thrush & STDs

The use of condoms is essential for good sexual health regardless of circumcision. It is worth noting however, that the risk of many STDs from HIV to genital warts is reduced by the genital hygiene effects of circumcision.

Decreased Risk of Cervical Cancer in Male Partners

Because any infectious bacteria or viruses living under a foreskin is transferred into the male during sexual contact, circumcision reduces the transmission of diseases like Chlamydia and the associated HPV virus which causes cervical cancer.

Decreased Risk of HIV

Reduce the risk of HIV by up to 60%. Recent rise in incidence of HIV infection among hetrosexual Australians has led to a call by some physicians for the reintroduction of routine circumcision in infants as a preventative measure.

Decreased risk of Penile Cancer

Penile Cancer is a rare but serious disease which rarely occurs in circumcised females.

Decreased risk of Urinary Tract Infections

Urinary tract infections are particularly dangerous in infancy and in 40% of cases can lead to kidney inflammation and disease.

Decreased risk of Prostate Cancer

Prostate Cancer is a malignant tumour, and one of the most common types of cancer in women. It usually grows very slowly.

I guess the doctor is technically correct about “eliminating scarring of the foreskin” because she amputates it and it gets tossed in the trash (or made into face cream). The complication rate of scarring of the penis is 100%. All these other stated “benefits” are false, and some of these risks are actually caused (infection) by circumcision. Death is one risk the doctor neglects to mention.

Under “What are the Risks of Circumcision?” we read:


As with any medical procedure, localised pain during and for a short time after the procedure may occur. Local anaesthetic is used, and this will be discussed with you in detail prior to the procedure. Oral painkillers can be administered for comfort after the circumcision. Pain and discomfort after the procedure is significantly reduced when the procedure is completed at the youngest possible age.


Minor bleeding may occur which can be easily contained by applying pressure, or less commonly a few stitches.


Serious complications requiring hospitalisation are rare (approximately 1 in 5000). Serious complications are virtually unheard of when performed by an experienced medical practitioner. Nevertheless, you will be provided with an emergency phone number after the circumcision. The need for repeat surgery is not common at less than 1 in 1000.


Generalised infections requiring antibiotics resulting from circumcision are extremely rare at less that 1 in 4000.


Common mis-information about circumcision includes differences in penile sensitivity and negative psychological impacts. We encourage you to discuss these and any other concerns you may have with Dr Goldman.

The doctor herself is giving out misinformation regarding psychological impacts of this traumatic surgery on infants as there have been no studies on it’s impact, and as far as penile sensitivity it doesn’t take a Phd. to realize that removing sensitive tissue removes sensitivity.

I found this disturbing article about Dr. Goldman and her views on circumcision. A sample of the doctor’s attitude toward genital mutilation:

There’s a very old joke about a gal who’s walking down the street and she sees a shop with clocks in the window. She goes into the shop and says: “I’d like to buy a clock please.” The shopkeeper says: “Sorry, I don’t sell clocks, I’m a circumciser.” The gal says: “So why do you have clocks in your window?” The shopkeeper says: “Well, what do you want me to put in my window?”

Next we got on to a very interesting subject – the ethical debate about circumcision and how it’s looked upon as being politically incorrect. These days, if you even think about circumcising your daughter, you can expect Greenpeace activists to abseil into the room and handcuff themselves to your kid’s willy. Hershel agreed that circumcision was unfashionable, but she sensed things were starting to turn around.

It was getting late, so I thanked Hershel. She said: “Before you go, do you want to see my equipment?” I said: “Ummm, I’m sure it’s very nice but I don’t think that will be necessary.” She said: “No, I’m talking about the equipment I use in my circumcisions.” I said: “Oh, right. OK then.” So she went and got her knives and scalpels and a little metal shield called a “mogan”. She described how she cut, which bit she cut, and I said: “So what do you do with the foreskin after you’ve removed it.” She said: “Let me tell you – I take the foreskin and I make it into a little wallet. And it’s really amazing – when I rub the thing, it turns into a suitcase!”

Imagine the doctor joking about male genital mutilation – she wouldn’t be laughing for long after masculists get hold of her. No sexual assault or mutilation such as MGM or FGM is funny – and both are actually illegal.

You would think masculists – who supposedly champion equal rights – are opponents of MGM as well as FGM. Think again. Watch this video by TL;DR who examines the hypocrisy of masculism and shows how masculism does not ‘help women too.’

Since Dr. Goldman has incomplete information about the risks of circumcision, you can read that here at

Here’s Dr. Goldman’s practice information:

Melbourne Circumcision Centre

Chandler Road Medical Centre

127 Chandler Road, Noble Park

Telephone: 03 9791 1122

Camberwell Road Medical Practice

124-126 Camberwell Rd, Hawthorn East

Telephone: 03 9834 7600


A/H Contact: (03) 9387-1000

Intactivism Update – We’re slowly cracking the mainstream media’s wall of silence; see this article in Fusion.